November 19, 2026
Host
I knew things had gotten a little weird when I had to announce that I was taking myself out of the running for a job I had never applied for. The job was Relief Society president. The election was imaginary. The campaigning, from where I sat, felt surprisingly real.
Host
I was already a counselor in the Relief Society presidency, and women had started gossiping about who the next president would be. People kept asking me if I thought it would be me. Once you’ve been asked that question enough times, you start to wonder if there’s a bulletin board somewhere with everybody’s picture on it and a little arrow moving up and down.
Host
I remember thinking, I feel like I’m running for class president. And I didn’t enjoy running for class president as a grown woman. I had two boys to raise. I had a job. I had books to write. I was too old to make a poster that said VOTE FOR SHANNON and too tired to bring cupcakes to sway the undecided.
Host
But underneath the absurdity was a question that stayed with me. When did being a good Mormon become a competition? And who decided what counted as winning?
Host
I’m Shannon L. Alder. I’m a Latter-day Saint author and therapist, and I’ve written several books for Latter-day Saint readers. Welcome to Latter-day Saint Unfiltered. This is not an anti-Mormon podcast. I’m a Latter-day Saint. I believe in Jesus Christ. And I believe my faith is strong enough to survive an honest question. Sometimes the best person to ask why church can feel strange is somebody who loves it enough to keep showing up.
Host
Eventually, the bishop did ask me to serve as Relief Society president. And I said no. I can imagine somebody listening right now, folding laundry, who just stopped halfway through a towel. Yes. I said no.
Host
At the time, I was working as a therapist, writing books, and raising two boys. By the end of an ordinary day, I had already made approximately four thousand decisions, at least seven of which concerned whether the thing on the floor was clean enough to put back in the drawer.
Host
I also felt that God had already shown me something He wanted me to do. Writing books was a calling in my life. It was work I felt personally directed to do, and I was trying to give it the time and attention it deserved. I knew what adding a presidency would mean for my family and for the commitments I already had.
Host
And here’s the sentence I used to feel like I had to bury under all the respectable reasons. I just didn’t want to do it. I’m comfortable saying that now. There have been things I felt God wanted me to do that I had no desire to do at first. I know what it feels like to be stretched. I also know the feeling of saying yes because I’m afraid of what people will think if I say no. Those two experiences can look identical from the pew behind you. They feel very different when you’re the one taking the decision to God.
Host
People kept asking me about the presidency, so I finally told them I had declined. There were two women who, from what I could see, both wanted the calling. I remember how relieved they seemed when I announced I was out of the running. It felt like I’d been leading a race I hadn’t entered and had finally done them the courtesy of stepping off the track.
Host
I can laugh about it now. At the time it was unpleasant. There’s a particular loneliness in having people talk about your life as though it’s a decision they get to watch unfold. I was thinking about my boys, my work, and what I felt God had asked of me. The conversation around me seemed to be about who was ahead. I don’t know what was in those women’s hearts. A woman can sincerely want to lead and have good reasons for wanting to serve. What bothered me was how quickly the gossip turned a stewardship into a position people could win. Once we started talking that way, somebody was bound to feel like she’d lost.
Host
I respect my bishop. I also believe I can speak honestly with him about what I can give. He could ask me to serve, and I could tell him what was happening in my life. Both of us could take that conversation seriously. You know your relationship with Heavenly Father and Jesus Christ more intimately than anybody watching you from across the Relief Society room. Take the invitation to Them. Tell God what scares you, what you’re already carrying, and what you honestly want. Give Him room to confirm what you feel or to correct you. I trust Him to let me know when I’m getting something wrong. Sometimes that comes through prayer. Sometimes it comes through a verse that keeps working on me, or wise counsel I have to think about for a while.
Host
James 1:5 says, “If any of you lack wisdom, let him ask of God.” As Latter-day Saints, we tell the story of a young man who took that verse seriously enough to go into a grove of trees and ask his own question. I think a grown woman should feel equally free to go into her bedroom, shut the door, and pray, “Heavenly Father, I have three people who need me tonight and an invitation to take on something else. Help me see what You want me to do.”
Host
A no can be faithful. Some of us need to hear that without a whole paragraph of qualifications. You can say no to a calling, and you can keep showing up the next Sunday as a full member of the ward. You can sing, take the sacrament, love the people around you, and go home without making a closing argument for your decision.
Host
The Relief Society presidency is one example. We find plenty of other ways to keep score. Take missions. One of my sons came home without baptizing anyone. My other son baptized many people. If all you had was a tally, you might assume you knew something about which of my boys had the more meaningful mission. As their mother, I got to see changes a tally could never have captured. I saw growth in the son who came home with zero baptisms, and I’m proud of what both sons gave.
Host
Paul gives us a way to think about that in 1 Corinthians 3:6. “I have planted, Apollos watered; but God gave the increase.” Think about how much good one missionary can do before anybody sees an outcome. He may be the first person who listens to somebody long enough to hear why they’re angry with God. Years later, somebody else may be there when that person is ready to talk again. Neither one will know the whole story.
Host
We also compare when people get married, where they marry, how many children they have, and what those children do when they grow up. A piece of good news comes in, and somewhere in the middle of being happy for our friend, we start wondering what her news says about us. Her daughter is getting married. Suddenly we’re thinking about our own daughter, who was perfectly happy fifteen minutes ago and is now apparently behind on a schedule she never agreed to. And spare a thought for the woman sitting through the lesson on eternal families who’s spending her first Sunday at church after her divorce. She got dressed. She drove there. She stood in the foyer for a minute deciding whether she could bear to go in. If we knew what it took for her to walk through that door, we might spend less time asking her what happened and more time saving her a seat.
Host
There’s another kind of competition that’s easy to miss because you can do it entirely inside your head. You hear a beautiful testimony and start grading the last one you gave. Somebody says she gets up at five to read her scriptures, and you wonder whether it counts that you read three verses in the parking lot before your dental cleaning. Then you hear she makes breakfast for her children every morning and begin to suspect Heavenly Father has a spreadsheet.
Host
For the record, I’ve had spiritual thoughts in parking lots. I’ve also had some very unspiritual thoughts in church parking lots, particularly when I was trying to leave. My point is that a real life with God is going to have a little more variety in it than the version we tell from the pulpit.
Host
Jesus told a story in Luke 18 about a Pharisee and a publican who went to the temple to pray. The Pharisee talked to God about his fasting and tithing, and managed to work in how thankful he was that he wasn’t like other people. The publican simply prayed, “God be merciful to me a sinner.” I always think about how easily I could hear that story and leave feeling pleased I’m more humble than the Pharisee. Which is a remarkably efficient way to miss the entire lesson.
Host
Sometimes comparison comes out as superiority. Sometimes it comes out as shame. I can leave church admiring the woman who brought a whole meal to somebody and still go home feeling like a failure because the most I could do that week was make a phone call. Meanwhile, the person on the other end of that call might have been waiting all day for someone to remember her.
Host
One of my favorite questions in the New Testament comes near the end of John. Jesus has just had that tender conversation with Peter about feeding His sheep. Peter sees another disciple and asks, “Lord, and what shall this man do?” I recognize that impulse. I can have a perfectly good sense of what I’m supposed to do and still want a detailed briefing on what everybody else has been assigned. Jesus answers in John 21:22, “What is that to thee? follow thou me.”
Host
Imagine hearing that the next time you start wondering why somebody got the calling you thought you’d get. Or when you’re trying to work out whether somebody declined for a good enough reason. Jesus had given Peter sheep to care for. Peter could spend the afternoon comparing assignments, but those sheep would still be hungry.
Host
I want to be part of a ward where a woman can ask about a calling without anybody laughing at her ambition, and where another woman can decline without becoming the subject of three separate phone calls. I want somebody who just got released to get invited to lunch by the same people who used to call her every week. I want the woman who’s been quietly visiting her neighbor for six years to feel that the good she does matters, even if most of the ward has never heard about it.
Host
And I want to remember my part in making church feel that way. When I’m tempted to speculate about the next Relief Society president, I can ask the current one how she’s doing. When someone shares good news, I can enjoy it with her and let myself be happy for a whole minute before my brain tries to make it about me. And when somebody tells me she’s had to say no, I can take her at her word and still ask if she wants to sit with me Sunday.
Host
I’ve thought about the person who eventually accepted that calling. I hope people gave her room to learn. I hope somebody brought her dinner on a night she was too tired to cook. And I hope she had at least one friend who called just to ask how she was and didn’t need her to find a substitute for anything.
Host
Mormonism is a culture like jews or amish. Its more than church attendance. Its your whole life. When you see your church attendance as a social club rather than worship these competition games tend to crop up. This competition lead my mom to leave the church. Atleast one reason why she did. People need to knock it off. Church is not high school. There should be no cliches and the popular crowd. That sounds like common sense but I have been a member for years and see this still play out among members.
Host
I think I would’ve liked Relief Society a little more that year if, instead of asking whether I was going to be president, somebody had asked me, “Shannon, how are you doing with the boys and work and that book you’re trying to finish?” I would’ve had plenty to say. I might even have asked how she was doing. We probably would’ve found something better to talk about than who was in the lead.
Host
I’m Shannon L. Alder, and this is Latter-day Saint Unfiltered. If church has ever felt like a competition to you, I’d love to hear when you first noticed it and what helped you find your footing again. You can share the story without naming the ward. Some of us still have to go to the Christmas party. If you like this podcast subscribe on You tube. You can learn more about me on shannonalder.com