November 19, 2026
Host
Welcome back to the podcast! Today we're diving into a fanfiction that has taken the Warrior Nun fandom by storm. It's called 'come back (even as a shadow, even as a dream)' by karatam. It's a post-season 2 fix-it fic with a twist. We're going to break it down, discuss the characters, the themes, and why it's such a compelling read.
Guest
Thanks for having me. I'm excited to talk about this one. It's a heavy fic, but it's so well done. It picks up three months after Ava disappears into the portal. Beatrice is grieving and traveling across Europe, unable to move on. She teams up with Jillian Salvius to try to bring Ava back. But when she succeeds, Ava comes back... different.
Host
Let's start with the prologue. It's set in Amsterdam, and Beatrice is just going through the motions of being a tourist. The writing is so evocative. What did you think of that opening?
Guest
It's heartbreaking. Beatrice is in this beautiful city, surrounded by life and color, but she's completely detached. She's hypervigilant, tense, and just... empty. The line 'she has been grieving for someone who has not yet died' really stuck with me. It captures that limbo of not knowing if Ava is alive or dead.
Host
Yes, that line is powerful. And the contrast between the vibrant city and her inner emptiness is striking. She's been to six cities in three months, and she hates it. Why do you think she keeps traveling?
Guest
I think she's trying to honor Ava's dream of seeing the world. But it's hollow without her. She keeps turning to her right, expecting Ava to be there, making a comment or asking a question. But there's just silence. It's like she's walking in the footsteps of a ghost.
Host
And then she goes to a gay bar, which is a big step for her. She's exploring a part of herself that Ava helped her embrace. But even there, she feels removed. What did you make of that scene?
Guest
It's bittersweet. She's finally allowing herself to be in that space, but Ava isn't there to share it with her. The woman who buys her drink is a reminder of what she could have, but she turns down the dance because it's 'too soon since the last dancefloor.' It's a beautiful callback to their first dance in the show.
Host
Right, and then she ends up outside a church, looking at the stained glass, but she can't bring herself to go in. She's lost her faith. That's a huge shift for Beatrice, who was so devout.
Guest
It is. She's always found solace in prayer and worship, but now there's just silence. She can't feel God's presence because her heart is with Ava, and Ava is gone. It's a crisis of faith, but also a crisis of self. She's questioning everything.
Host
That prologue sets the emotional stakes perfectly. Then we move to chapter one, where she goes to the Salvius compound. She finds the Arc still there, and Jillian is there too. They decide to work together to track the Halo's signature. What did you think of their partnership?
Guest
I love it. Jillian is a genius, and she's also grieving Michael. They bond over their shared loss and determination. It's a great use of the supporting cast. Jillian's line about being a 'demanding project manager' adds a bit of levity to the heavy situation.
Host
Yes, that was a nice touch. And then they start building prototypes, and they fail. And fail again. It's very realistic. Science is messy.
Guest
Exactly. They spend weeks trying to boost the signal, changing out detectors, and nothing works. It shows Beatrice's perseverance. She's not just sitting around; she's actively working to bring Ava back. It's a way for her to channel her grief into something productive.
Host
Now, the tag 'Ava comes back wrong' is a big draw. It's a popular trope in fanfiction. What does it mean for this story?
Guest
It means that Ava's return isn't a simple fix. Something is off. Maybe she's not entirely herself, or she brought something back with her. The fic explores the consequences of resurrection and the cost of tampering with other realms. It adds mystery and tension.
Host
And it prevents the reunion from being too easy. It forces the characters to work for their happy ending. The tag also promises a happy ending, so readers know it's not all doom and gloom.
Guest
Right, it's 'Angst with a Happy Ending.' So you go through the wringer, but you come out satisfied. The author balances the pain with moments of hope and even humor.
Host
Let's talk about the relationship between Beatrice and Ava. In the show, they had such a strong bond. How does the fic capture that?
Guest
It shows how much Ava changed Beatrice's life. Beatrice was used to being alone, and she was okay with it. But Ava made her feel seen and loved. Now, being alone feels like a loss. The line 'alone just means alone' is so poignant.
Host
Yes, it's like Ava rewired her entire existence. And now she's off balance, missing her other half. It's a beautiful depiction of grief and love.
Guest
And the author does a great job of showing Beatrice's internal monologue. We get her thoughts, her memories, her fears. It's very intimate.
Host
The writing style is quite lyrical. There are passages that feel almost like poetry. How does that affect the reading experience?
Guest
It draws you in. The descriptions are vivid, and the emotions are raw. You feel like you're inside Beatrice's head. The pacing is also well done; it knows when to linger and when to move forward.
Host
I want to challenge you on one thing. Some readers might find the pacing a bit slow in the middle chapters. Do you think the story could have been tightened?
Guest
That's a fair point. There are moments where the scientific details get a bit dense. But I think it serves a purpose. It shows the tedious, frustrating process of trying to achieve the impossible. And the emotional payoff is worth it.
Host
Fair enough. Let's talk about the supporting characters. We have Mother Superion, Camila, Lilith. They all appear in the fic. How are they used?
Guest
They're not forgotten. Each has their own arc. Lilith, in particular, has a complicated role given her transformation. The fic doesn't sideline them; they're part of the larger story.
Host
And Jillian's grief over Michael parallels Beatrice's over Ava. It's a nice mirror.
Guest
Yes, they're both mothers in mourning, in a way. Jillian lost her son to the portal, and Beatrice lost Ava. They understand each other without having to explain. It's a beautiful dynamic.
Host
Now, the fandom context. Warrior Nun was canceled, and fans are passionate. Fix-it fics like this are a way to cope. Why do you think this particular fic resonated so much?
Guest
Because it gives fans what they want: a reunion, but with stakes. It doesn't ignore the pain of the finale; it builds on it. And it's completed, so readers can binge it. The author is also well-known in the fandom for their writing.
Host
The title is 'come back (even as a shadow, even as a dream).' It's poetic. What does it mean to you?
Guest
It's a plea. Beatrice is willing to accept Ava in any form, even if she's not the same. It's about desperation and unconditional love. The parenthetical suggests that even a shadow or a dream would be enough.
Host
That's beautiful. And it sets the tone for the whole fic. Now, without giving too much away, how does Ava change when she comes back?
Guest
She's different. The fic explores the trauma of her experience and the lingering effects. She's not the same Ava who left. But the core of her is still there, and that's what matters.
Host
And Beatrice has to navigate that. She has to reconcile the Ava she remembers with the Ava who returned. It's a journey of acceptance.
Guest
Yes, and it's not easy. There are conflicts and challenges. But ultimately, it's about love conquering all.
Host
Let's talk about the themes. Love, loss, grief, hope, identity, sacrifice. The fic handles them with care. Which theme resonated most with you?
Guest
I think the theme of identity is fascinating. What makes Ava, Ava? Is it her memories, her personality, or something else? The fic explores that in depth.
Host
And sacrifice. Beatrice is willing to sacrifice everything to bring Ava back, even her own peace of mind.
Guest
Yes, she turns her back on Ava's final wish. That's a huge conflict. She's putting her own desires above what Ava wanted. But it's out of love.
Host
Do you think that's selfish? Or is it understandable?
Guest
It's understandable. Grief makes us do irrational things. And Ava's wish was for Beatrice to live, but Beatrice can't live without her. It's a catch-22.
Host
The fic also has some beautiful religious imagery. Beatrice's crisis of faith is a recurring motif. How does that play out?
Guest
She's lost her connection to God because she feels abandoned. But in a way, her love for Ava becomes a kind of faith. She's devoted to bringing her back. It's a shift from divine faith to human love.
Host
That's a powerful interpretation. Now, let's talk about the ending. It's tagged happy, so readers know it's coming. But is it a perfect happy ending?
Guest
It's earned. There are still challenges, but they overcome them together. It's satisfying. The author doesn't wrap everything up in a neat bow; there are lingering issues, but the core relationship is solid.
Host
I think that's what makes it so good. It's realistic. Life isn't perfect, but love can be.
Guest
Exactly. And the writing is so strong that you feel every emotion. I cried, I laughed, I cheered. It's a full experience.
Host
Let's talk about the author, karatam. They're known in the fandom for their thoughtful character work. How does this fic compare to their other works?
Guest
I think it's their best. They've grown as a writer. The plotting is tight, the characters are well-developed, and the emotional beats hit hard.
Host
The fic is 113,000 words across 12 chapters. That's a novel-length commitment. Do you think it's worth it?
Guest
Absolutely. It's a binge-worthy read. The chapters are well-paced, and there's always something happening. It never feels like a slog.
Host
And it's completed, so no waiting for updates. That's a plus.
Guest
Yes, that's a big draw for many readers.
Host
Let's talk about the fandom's reaction. The fic has a lot of kudos and comments. Why do you think it's so popular?
Guest
Because it fills a void. The show ended on a cliffhanger, and fans wanted closure. This fic provides that, but in a way that feels earned. It also respects the characters and their journeys.
Host
And it's Ava/Beatrice, which is the main ship. Fans are hungry for content.
Guest
Definitely. The ship is beloved, and this fic does them justice. It's a must-read for any fan.
Host
Let's talk about some specific scenes. The bridge scene in Amsterdam, the gay bar, the church. Which one stood out to you the most?
Guest
The church scene. Beatrice standing outside, unable to go in, looking at the stained glass. It's a powerful image of lost faith. And the line 'the path she wants to walk is at Ava's side, and Ava is gone' is devastating.
Host
Yes, that's a gut punch. And then there's the scene where she first sees the Arc again. She's tempted to blow it up. That's a great character moment.
Guest
I laughed at that. It's so Beatrice to have a violent impulse and then suppress it.
Host
And the banter with Jillian is fun. They have a good rapport.
Guest
Yes, it lightens the mood. Jillian's line about being a demanding project manager is perfect.
Host
Now, the 'comes back wrong' aspect. Without spoiling, what can you tell us about the nature of Ava's return?
Guest
I can say that it's not a simple resurrection. There are consequences. Ava is not entirely herself, and there's a mystery to unravel. It keeps you guessing.
Host
And it adds a layer of tension to the reunion. Beatrice has to fight for Ava all over again.
Guest
Yes, but that's what makes it compelling. Love is worth fighting for.
Host
Let's talk about the emotional impact on the reader. This fic will make you cry.
Guest
It will. But it also makes you smile. The happy ending is worth the tears.
Host
I think that's a good place to wrap up. Any final thoughts on the fic?
Guest
If you're a fan of Warrior Nun, or if you just love a good angsty romance with a happy ending, give this fic a read. It's beautifully written and deeply moving.
Host
And it's available on Archive of Our Own. We'll link it in the show notes. Thanks for joining us!
Guest
Thanks for having me.
Host
You mentioned the hypervigilance. There's a moment on the bridge where someone brushes past her, and she almost attacks them. How does the author convey that tension?
Guest
It's all in the physical details. She tenses, prepares her body for an attack. The knife strapped to her forearm. It shows how trauma has rewired her instincts. She's always on guard, even in a peaceful city.
Host
And it's a contrast to the beauty around her. She's in this picturesque place, but she's ready to fight. It's a great character detail.
Guest
Yes, it shows that she can't relax. She's been through so much. The war isn't over for her, even though Adriel is gone.
Host
Let's go back to the gay bar scene. You mentioned the callback to their first dance. Can you elaborate on that?
Guest
In the show, Beatrice and Ava share a dance at a bar, and it's a pivotal moment for Beatrice's self-acceptance. Here, she's in a similar space, but Ava isn't there. She turns down a dance because it's 'too soon.' It's a painful reminder of what she's lost.
Host
That's so poignant. And it shows how much Ava helped her come out of her shell. Now she's back to being alone, but it feels different.
Guest
Exactly. She's not the same person she was before Ava. She's changed, but she's also stuck.
Host
The church scene is also powerful. She can't go in. What does that say about her state of mind?
Guest
It says she's lost her anchor. Faith was a huge part of her life, but now it feels empty. She's looking for something to believe in, and that something is Ava. But Ava is gone, so she's adrift.
Host
And the stained glass window with Jesus staring down at her. It's like she's being judged, or maybe she's judging herself.
Guest
Yes, it's a moment of reckoning. She's questioning everything she's ever believed. It's a crisis of faith that mirrors her crisis of self.
Host
Let's talk about the science in the fic. Jillian and Beatrice working on the detector. It's quite detailed. Did you find it believable?
Guest
I did. It's not overly technical, but it feels real. They have setbacks, they troubleshoot, they get frustrated. It's a nice change from fics where solutions come too easily.
Host
And the soldering fails. That's a nice touch.
Guest
Yes, it adds a bit of humor. It shows that even geniuses struggle with basic tasks sometimes.
Host
The balance of angst and humor is well done. Can you give an example of a moment that made you smile?
Guest
The scene where Beatrice is tempted to blow up the Arc. It's such a visceral reaction. And then Jillian appears and she has to suppress it. It's very in-character.
Host
And the banter between them. Jillian's line about being a demanding project manager. It's a nice moment of levity.
Guest
Yes, it breaks the tension. It reminds you that these are real people with personalities, not just grief machines.
Host
Now, the mystery of what came back with Ava. Without spoiling, how does the author build that tension?
Guest
Through small details. Ava's behavior is slightly off. There are hints of something else. It keeps you on edge, wondering what's going to happen.
Host
And it makes the happy ending feel earned. They have to work for it.
Guest
Exactly. It's not a simple fix. It's a journey. And that's what makes it satisfying.
Host
Let's talk about the character voices. Beatrice is very formal and precise in her speech. How does the author capture that?
Guest
She uses complete sentences, no contractions, and a lot of internal reflection. It's very in-character. Even in her thoughts, she's measured. It contrasts with Ava's more impulsive way of speaking.
Host
And Jillian is more scientific, but also maternal. It's a nice balance.
Guest
Yes, she's brilliant but also vulnerable. The author shows both sides.
Host
The fic also uses a lot of sensory details. The smell of coffee, the sound of bells, the feel of the knife. How does that enhance the story?
Guest
It grounds the emotions in physical reality. You can feel Beatrice's tension, her grief. It makes the story more immersive.
Host
There's also a lot of religious symbolism. The church, the stained glass, the prayers. How does that tie into the themes?
Guest
It's a way to show Beatrice's internal conflict. She's torn between her faith and her love for Ava. The symbolism adds depth.
Host
The ending is satisfying. Without spoiling, what can you say about the final chapter?
Guest
It's emotional and cathartic. There's a sense of closure, but also a new beginning. It's a happy ending that feels earned.