November 17, 2026
Host
The turkey had been out of the oven for eleven minutes when Aunt Linda asked her daughter, 'Are you really leaving at four?' Megan had already answered this question in a text on Monday, in a phone call on Wednesday, and in the driveway twelve minutes ago. She and her husband had promised to stop by his parents’ house for dessert. 'Yes, Mom,' Megan said. 'We’re still leaving at four.' Linda set down the gravy boat. 'I just think it’s interesting how people make time for the family they actually want to see.' Everyone suddenly became fascinated by the rolls. Megan’s husband took a sip of water. Her brother, who’d spent the entire morning arguing with a man online about how to brine poultry, suddenly had nothing to contribute. Megan felt herself reaching for the usual response. Explain the schedule. Mention how early they’d arrived. Remind her mother that she’d made the sweet potatoes from scratch. Maybe offer to stay another hour. Then her eight-year-old looked up and said, 'Grandma, you can have my roll if you’re still hungry.' It was the first sensible offer anyone had made all afternoon. Maybe your version of that conversation happens in the driveway, before you’ve even taken your coat off. Maybe it starts Tuesday night with a text that says, 'Just wondering if anybody was planning to tell me what we’re doing this year.' And there you are, standing in the grocery store with a bag of marshmallows in your hand, already rehearsing your defense.
Host
Before we dive in, I want to take a moment to wish my cohost, Pastor Jake O’Connell, well. He’s on vacation this week with his family. We miss him, but he absolutely deserves this time to rest and recharge. So Jake, if you’re listening, enjoy every minute. Now, let me introduce myself properly. I’m Shannon L. Alder, a life coach and author of The Narcissistic Abuse Recovery Bible. Welcome to the Toxic Relationships Podcast. I’m so glad you’re here.
Host
If you’re watching on YouTube, please hit that subscribe button. It really helps us reach more people who might need this message. And while you’re at it, give us a like on Facebook. We love connecting with you there. Okay, let’s get into today’s topic.
Host
Today we’re talking about why Thanksgiving can bring out familiar patterns in someone who uses guilt, criticism, or conflict to get their way. And more importantly, what you can do when you recognize those patterns coming. As you listen, think about what typically happens after you’ve made a reasonable decision. A relative can be genuinely disappointed that you’re leaving early and still say, 'I’ll miss you. Drive safely.' Pay attention when the disappointment regularly turns into a family-wide effort to make changing your mind easier than keeping it. That’s the difference we’re exploring today.
Host
Reason number one: They want the holiday to revolve around them. Every Thanksgiving has a natural rotation of attention. Someone has a new baby. Someone brings a pie they actually made. Your nephew, who used to eat only beige food, announces he ate a green bean at school. People are allowed to have their little moments. But for a relative who expects to be the center of things, somebody else’s good news can feel like being left out. They may interrupt with a complaint, tell an embarrassing story about the person everyone is celebrating, or pick that exact moment to announce that they were deeply hurt by something that happened in 2009. You can see how quickly it works. Your niece says she got a promotion. Your mother sighs and says, 'Well, some of us never had anyone helping us get ahead.' And just like that, your niece is reassuring Grandma instead of telling you about the job she worked three years to get. So what can you do this Thanksgiving? Return to the person who was speaking. 'Emma, you were telling us about your new job. What will you be doing?' You can even continue that conversation in the kitchen while you refill your drinks. It gives Emma a chance to finish and saves you from spending fifteen minutes investigating whether her promotion was insensitive to Grandma. At the Last Supper, the disciples got into a dispute about which of them should be considered the greatest. Jesus answered by pointing to his own example of serving them. He had a room full of people thinking about rank. He talked about what they could do for one another. You can practice a little of that at your own table. Ask your shy nephew a follow-up question. Thank the person who peeled ten pounds of potatoes. Listen long enough for someone to finish the story they came to tell you.
Host
Reason number two: They use family traditions to control your choices. It’s amazing what can become a sacred family tradition the moment you suggest changing it. 'We’ve always eaten at two.' You’ve eaten at two twice. Last year you ate at five because Uncle Rick was trying to deep-fry a partially frozen turkey and the rest of the family was in the driveway praying over a fire extinguisher. Thanksgiving involves a lot of little decisions about whose house, what time, who brings the rolls, and whether your kids will spend part of the day with another set of grandparents. For someone who takes your independence personally, any one of those decisions can become a test of loyalty. You thought you were coordinating dessert. They heard you give another family equal billing. The pressure often gets stronger when you start explaining. If you say the kids get tired, they’ll tell you the kids can nap there. If you say you have another invitation, they’ll tell you to cancel it. If you say your husband wants to see his parents, suddenly the entire family has thoughts about your marriage. What you can do this Thanksgiving? Send a simple message before Thursday. 'We’ll be there at noon and leave at four. I’m bringing sweet potatoes.' If someone presses you, try, 'I know you wanted us to stay longer. We’re leaving at four.' And then give yourself enough time to actually be in the car at four. In some families, saying goodbye is a forty-five-minute activity involving four hugs, a missing child’s shoe, and a container of gravy that nobody has a lid for. Jesus says in Matthew 5:37, 'Let your communication be, Yea, yea, Nay, nay.' There’s a relief in speaking plainly. You can say yes to lunch and mean it. You can say no to staying for dinner and mean that, too.
Host
Reason number three: They know which comment will put you on the defensive. 'Are you going back for seconds?' That sentence can mean I’m taking the potatoes to the kitchen, would you like some more? It can also be delivered by a relative who has been monitoring your plate since the Reagan administration. You probably know the difference. A person who regularly gets personal during family gatherings may have learned which topics draw you into an argument. Your weight. Your divorce. Your parenting. Your faith. Your decision to stop explaining the divorce, which apparently is itself a topic for discussion. Then comes the little laugh. 'I’m kidding. You’re so sensitive.' Now you’re defending your sense of humor while they get to keep commenting on your life. This can be particularly effective in front of an audience. You feel pressure to be polite, the people nearby want the awkward moment to pass, and the relative knows you’re unlikely to say what you’d say if you were alone together. What you can do this Thanksgiving? Pick one sentence for the subject that tends to come up. 'Please leave my weight out of the conversation.' Or, 'I’m keeping the details of my divorce private.' Say it once. If the comments continue, take your plate and move. You are allowed to enjoy your pie at the kids’ table. They have better gossip anyway, and most of it concerns who cheated at Uno. In Nehemiah 6:2–3, Sanballat and Geshem repeatedly try to get Nehemiah to leave the work of rebuilding Jerusalem’s wall and meet with them. He answers, 'I am doing a great work, so that I cannot come down.' He keeps working. Your great work on Thursday may be helping your daughter beat you at Uno, sitting with your dad while he tells a story, or making it through a meal without explaining your body to anyone. Give those things your time. Let the comment sit there without you.
Host
Reason number four: They use gratitude and faith to make you feel obligated. 'After everything I’ve done for you, you can’t give me one day?' There’s something particularly painful about hearing that on Thanksgiving. You are grateful for some of the things that person has done. You remember who brought groceries when you were sick, who helped when money was tight, who taught you to make the stuffing everyone still asks for. That history matters to you. It’s precisely why the guilt works. Maybe the request is to stay longer. Maybe it’s to hug someone who has hurt you. Maybe you’re told, 'A Christian would forgive,' right before someone brings up a subject you’ve asked them to leave alone. Nobody asks what happened, or what a sincere repair might look like. They want you in the family photo in twelve minutes, preferably smiling. What you can do this Thanksgiving? Be specific about the gratitude and hold to your decision. 'I appreciate that you helped me when I was sick. I’m still going home at four.' Or, if you’re asked to have a conversation you aren’t ready for, 'I’ll wish him a happy Thanksgiving. I’m keeping that conversation for another day.' Paul writes in Romans 12:18, 'If it be possible, as much as lieth in you, live peaceably with all men.' I’m grateful for those first few words. If it be possible. Paul leaves room for the fact that we each have a part in how we treat one another. You can speak kindly and keep your plans. How someone responds to your answer belongs to them. And if somebody tells you that gratitude means you owe them unrestricted access to your time, think about how you give to people you love. When you bring someone a casserole after surgery, do you imagine yourself saying three years later, 'I gave you a nine-by-thirteen lasagna, so I’ll be deciding where your children spend Thursday'? You probably hope they liked the lasagna. You might want your dish back. That seems fair.
Host
Reason number five: They create a crisis when you’re about to leave. You survived dinner. The pie was lovely. You’ve located both of your children and most of their belongings. Your hand is on the doorknob when someone says, 'I wasn’t going to tell you this today, but apparently your sister has a problem with you.' Of course. We’re doing a family investigation in the entryway. One child is wearing a coat and one sock. The other is holding a paper plate of pie at an angle that makes you deeply uncomfortable. Sometimes the last-minute issue comes in a text after you get home. 'Everyone noticed how you acted.' Or you get a call from a sibling who says, 'Mom’s crying. Can you just call her so I don’t have to deal with this?' If you usually stay to sort things out, the people around you can come to expect it. A complaint at the door has bought another hour before. A vague accusation has gotten you to call back and ask which people, what behavior, and why nobody mentioned a word of it while you were all doing dishes together. What you can do this Thanksgiving? Give ordinary family conflicts a time and place. 'If she wants to talk to me, she can call me this weekend. We’re heading home now.' If the group texts start while you’re putting your kids to bed, mute the thread and decide the next day whether anything needs a reply. Sometimes the crisis comes after you leave. You get a text that says, 'You left without saying goodbye to Aunt Carol.' Or 'Everyone noticed you didn’t help with dishes.' Here’s the thing: you don’t have to respond immediately. You can wait until the next day. You can say, 'I’m sorry I missed Aunt Carol. I’ll call her this week.' And then actually call her if you want to. But you don’t owe an instant defense. In Luke 5:15–16, as news about Jesus spread and crowds came to hear him, he withdrew to pray. I think about that when I feel as though every ping on my phone is one more person I owe an immediate answer. There are evenings when the most honest prayer I have is, 'Lord, help me put this phone on the charger and go to bed.'
Host
Before Thursday, decide what you’ll do. Picture the moment that tends to throw you off. Is it the first little dig? The pressure to stay? The call on the drive home? Pick one response while you’re sitting somewhere quiet and nobody is holding a gravy boat. If you’re visiting, decide when you’ll leave and how you’ll get home. If someone is going with you, agree on the plan beforehand, including what you’ll do if you want to leave early. If you’re hosting, tell guests when the gathering ends. If somebody brings up a private conflict at the table, you can say, 'We’re putting that conversation aside for today.' Then ask who wants coffee. There is almost always someone who wants coffee. If you’re hosting, you can also set a clear end time in your invitation. 'We’ll be serving dinner at two and wrapping up by six.' That gives everyone a shared expectation. And if someone tries to start a conflict, you can say, 'Let’s enjoy our meal. We can talk about that another time.' Then pass the mashed potatoes. If you’re spending Thanksgiving elsewhere, a brief 'We’ve made other plans this year. I hope you have a good Thanksgiving' can be the whole message. Make a plan for your own day so you have something to look forward to after you send it. There may be a moment on Thursday when you’re tempted to watch the most difficult person at the table to see whether you’re allowed to enjoy yourself. When you catch yourself doing that, look around. Who came because they like being with you? Who’s doing something kind that nobody has noticed? Did you even taste the pie you waited all year for? Go back for a bite. Ask your niece about her new job. At four, find the shoe, thank whoever cooked, and head to the car.
Host
Now, I know some of you might be thinking, 'Shannon, isn’t it ungrateful to leave early when someone worked so hard on the meal?' Let me push back on that gently. Leaving at the time you said you would is not ungrateful. It’s honest. What’s ungrateful is expecting someone to read your mind and then punishing them for not doing it. Gratitude and boundaries can coexist. You can thank your host for the wonderful meal and still leave when you said you would. In fact, that’s often the most respectful thing you can do—for yourself and for them. So give yourself permission to be both grateful and boundaried.
Host
Let’s close with a Thanksgiving prayer. Lord, thank You for the people who make room for us at their tables and in their lives. For those of us who are already worried about Thursday, give us wisdom to know what we can offer and courage to say it kindly. Help us listen without taking on every accusation, and be gentle with ourselves when an old family pattern catches us off guard. Let us notice the good that’s right in front of us. And when it’s time to go home, help us leave with love. In Jesus’s name, amen.
Host
Thank you so much for joining me today. I hope this episode helps you protect your peace this Thanksgiving while still showing up with love. Remember, you can be grateful and still set boundaries. You can be kind and still leave at four. If this resonated with you, please share it with someone who might need it. Subscribe on YouTube, like us on Facebook, and leave a comment about how you’re planning to protect your peace this holiday. And remember, you’re not alone in this. Many people face these same dynamics. The fact that you’re listening means you’re already taking a step toward healthier holidays. So give yourself credit for that. Jake will be back next week, and we’ll continue this conversation. Until then, happy Thanksgiving, and go enjoy that pie. You deserve it.